Some of my more recent thinking about leadership has come from taking on a responsibility that I did not feel entirely prepared for.
I had agreed to help facilitate part of a whole-school self-study process. It involved working with colleagues from different areas of the school, examining evidence, interpreting expectations, and bringing together a written account of our findings.
It was an interesting opportunity, particularly because it extended beyond my usual teaching and departmental responsibilities.
But I was also conscious that I was taking on something unfamiliar.
I understood the broad purpose of the work, but understanding what needed to be achieved and feeling confident about how to achieve it were not quite the same thing. I wanted to make a meaningful contribution, and I wanted to do the work well. At the same time, I was aware of how much I still needed to understand.
I think part of me had expected that taking on greater responsibility would become easier as I gained experience. That confidence would gradually replace uncertainty, and that I would eventually reach a point where I simply felt ready.
This experience has made me question that assumption.
As I worked through the process, I found myself moving between reading guidance, examining evidence, discussing interpretations, and making decisions about how to bring everything together.
Some aspects became clearer quite quickly. Others required more consideration. I was learning to distinguish between describing what a school does, evaluating how effectively something is working, and deciding what conclusions could reasonably be drawn from the available evidence.
What I found particularly interesting was that completing the work and feeling certain about it were two different things.
I could organise the information, make reasoned judgements, and develop a substantial draft. I could also recognise areas where a second perspective would be valuable.
And, if I am honest, there were moments when I wanted someone to tell me that I was approaching it in the right way.
That feeling was not entirely comfortable.
I have increasingly wanted to demonstrate that I am capable of taking on broader leadership responsibilities. Admitting uncertainty can feel difficult when part of what you are trying to establish is your readiness to lead.
Yet the alternative, simply appearing confident regardless of whether I had sufficient understanding, did not seem particularly responsible either.
This created a question that stayed with me: at what point does seeking reassurance become a lack of confidence, and when is it actually an important part of exercising good judgement?
Taking responsibility does not necessarily mean having certainty. It means being prepared to make decisions, explain them, and remain open to reconsidering them.
My MSc study has given me another way of thinking about this.
In exploring ethical leadership, I have become more aware that professional judgement often involves weighing considerations that cannot be resolved through a single rule or straightforward answer. Recognising uncertainty is not necessarily a problem. The question is what we do with it.
That does not mean a leader can continually defer decisions until everyone agrees or every possible concern has been resolved. There is a responsibility to make progress, sometimes with incomplete information.
But there is also a responsibility to recognise the limitations of our own knowledge, seek other perspectives when appropriate, and remain willing to revise our understanding.
I am beginning to see these as connected responsibilities rather than competing expectations.
Looking back at the self-study experience, I can see that I did take responsibility for the work. I developed my understanding of the process, organised and drafted the contribution, drew on colleagues' perspectives, and submitted it for review.
I also sought feedback because I recognised that the work would benefit from being examined beyond my own interpretation.
The process has not suddenly made me feel ready for every leadership responsibility. If anything, I have become more conscious of the complexity involved in taking responsibility for decisions and work that extend beyond my immediate experience.
But I think the nature of my uncertainty is changing.
Earlier in my career, uncertainty sometimes made me reluctant to step forward. I tended to associate readiness with having enough experience and confidence to know what I was doing before taking on something new.
Now, I am beginning to recognise that some of that understanding can only develop through accepting responsibility and working through the challenges it brings.
Perhaps the important distinction is not between feeling ready and feeling uncertain, but between allowing uncertainty to prevent action and learning how to respond to it thoughtfully.
I still want to become more confident in my judgement. I also want to remain comfortable questioning it.
Increasingly, I think both are part of becoming a better leader.